Including Child, In Mass Shooting … Harlens was a student at Westchester High School in Los Angeles, California. "A Love Song for Latasha" is streaming now on Netflix. If you’ve seen anything of Latasha’s life, it’s likely the final seconds of her existence. The jury found Soon guilty of voluntary manslaughter. Harlins then turned her back to Du and attempted to leave the store when Soon Ja Du pulled out a gun and shot her in the back of the head, killing Latasha Harlins instantly. The entire event was captured on the store’s security camera and the tape was used in the trial of Soon Ja Du. members. Latasha Harlins (January 1, 1976 – March 16, 1991) was a 15-year-old African-American girl who was fatally shot by Soon Ja Du (Hangul:순자두), a 51-year-old Korean American convenience store-owner. A videotape played Monday in a Los Angeles courtroom showed that Latasha Harlins had turned away from a scuffle with a Korean grocer when the black teen-ager was shot in the back of the head. The death of Latasha Harlins, which was recorded on security footage, and the la… Her defense was an accidental shooting by way of self-defense. In March of 1991, 15-year-old Latasha Harlins was killed by one of the owners of the Empire Liquor convenience store in Los Angeles, Calif. Latasha had entered the store to buy a container of orange juice for $1.79 when she was fatally shot by Soon Ja … names, ages, roles of Billy and Charles Du, Du's lawyer, video proof, Tupac. Just thirteen days after Rodney was beaten, a fifteen-year-old Black girl named Latasha Harlins entered the Empire Liquor Market in South Central Los Angeles. Let me go.’ ”. Given the emotional content of the film, she also didn’t want to retraumatize her subjects. Some members of Harlins’ family wept as they watched the March 16 shooting on television monitors. In one of the best games in NCAA Final Four history, UCLA did not deserve to lose on one of the most unlikely final shots in tournament history. Her death happened thirteen days after the videotape of the Rodney King beating was released. I wanted to look at the video from the security camera that the police used. This is not the movies. A police officer testified later that injuries Du received may not have all come from the fight with Harlins. Take a look and compare. Latasha, 15, was shot in the back of the head by a Korean woman who owned a South Los Angeles liquor store. Harlins, after telling Du she intended to pay for the juice, hit the grocer twice in the face as Du held onto her clothing, the witness said. He said Du feared for her safety because her son had been beaten and forced to pay extortion at the store and she was aware of nearby merchants who had been killed during robberies. An appeals court voted to uphold the sentence just a week before the acquittal of the policemen who beat King set off the 1992 riots. The short documentary, ‘A … “We had to put in the time, the dedication, and the work to let this exist fully, because too often her story was just reduced down to these last moments of her life.”, Like us on Facebook to see similar stories, US vaccine rollout envied in Canada; Britain plans return to concerts, sports events: Live COVID-19 updates, The Biden administration launches a $500,000 contest to improve face mask designs. In network TV, seeing a breakout star bolt from a hit show would be unusual. She reached across the counter to grab the teen, who in turn punched Du. The jury recommended the maximum sentence for Soon, but the judge Joyce Karlin over ruled the recommendation. Until she saw footage of her best friend being shot to death on the news, O’Bard “never knew what terror was,” she says in the film. “What happens when you don’t show people the footage and the first time they see it is when they’re in the audience?” she says. Playground dedicated to Latasha Harlins, 30 years after killing March 17, 2021, 12:19 AM A somber anniversary was marked Tuesday for family, friends, and an entire community still heartbroken over the wrongful shooting of a young, Black girl. Netflix. For people who do not yet qualify for a COVID-19 vaccine in their area, there are limited options for obtaining a coveted dose. The Harlins shooting is one of several confrontations between Korean grocers in South-Central and their customers. The best-known fact about Harlins, whose friends and family called her Tasha, is that she was killed over a $1.79 bottle of juice. The best-known fact about Harlins, whose friends and family called her Tasha, is that she was killed over a $1.79 bottle of juice. The filmmaker deploys experimental reenactments to re-create the memories of two of the women closest to Latasha, her best friend Tybie O’Bard and her cousin Shinese Harlins. Plaschke: UCLA didn’t deserve to get Laettnered after playing like champions vs. Gonzaga. In the years following Harlins’ killing, rapper Tupac Shakur provided her with a little hint of justice by ensuring that her name would never be completely forgotten. For the second time in three months, the people who knew Latasha Harlins best and who miss her most gathered in front of her mural at Algin Sutton Recreation Center. “I wanted them to always know what was going to happen in the film, to be prepared for seeing themselves crying.”, Du was convicted of voluntary manslaughter and could have faced up to sixteen years in prison for killing Harlins. (Courtesy: KNBC) Harlins' death, and how Korean-Americans became 'the problem' 0 0. Now the keepers of his collection are making change with the museum at a critical juncture, Why is Regé-Jean Page leaving Netflix’s ‘Bridgerton?’. Within view of the store’s security cameras, she was shot in the back of the head by the store owner after a dispute over a bottle of orange juice. Show full articles without "Continue Reading" button for {0} hours. Latasha Harlins, 15, went into a corner store to buy orange juice and never came out. “When I was finally in my late twenties and learning about Latasha, I was completely shocked that I’d never heard about her,” the filmmaker told Esquire. In his opening statement, Du’s attorney, Charles Lloyd, contended that Du pulled a handgun in self-defense and accidentally shot Harlins. There was no audio on the tape, but the prosecution’s first two witnesses--9-year-old Ismail Ali and his 13-year-old sister Lakeshia Combs--testified that there was a sharp exchange and name-calling by Du and Harlins. Henry E. Huntington busted unions and exploited Mexican labor. A videotape played Monday in a Los Angeles courtroom showed that Latasha Harlins had turned away from a scuffle with a Korean grocer when the black teen-ager was shot in … The shooting occurred just thirteen days after the recorded beating of Rodney King by L.A.P.D. Allison, who studied photojournalism before becoming a filmmaker, renders the young girls who stand in for Latasha and her playmates with the natural but studied eye of a street photographer. Een vijftienjarig meisje werd gedood omdat de winkelier dacht dat ze sinaasappelsap wilde stelen, terwijl ze het gewoon wilde kopen. Allison was barely preschool aged at the time of Latasha’s death, but though she grew up in South-Central Los Angeles, she knew only of Rodney King as the face of the city’s riots. O’Bard and Harlins speak of the struggles Latasha went through—her mother was murdered when she was just nine years old—but they also dwell on the mundane sweetness of her young life, including trips to the pool and the basketball courts, and playing “Stand by Me” on a jukebox at a local burger joint. “She was trying to walk out the door,” when she was shot, Lakeshia Combs testified. ‘They were so innocent’: Orange mass shooting shattered a family business; victims remembered. Some black activists say the incidents stemmed from racism on the part of the Koreans. “You bitch, you are trying to steal my orange juice,” the boy quoted Du as saying when Harlins approached the store’s counter with currency in her hand and the bottle of juice “halfway” protruding from her backpack. “Latasha’s best friend would always tell me, ‘Latasha’s going to make you work for this.’ And that’s something that I really believe,” she said. Can it pivot toward inclusivity? The Huntington Library has a history of inequity. Allison says that those who best loved the teenager have been “disappointed” in the way Latasha’s death has been covered, so she made sure to include them throughout the filmmaking process. The graphic images of the killing of 15-year-old Harlins, captured by a security camera inside the Empire Liquor Market in South-Central Los Angeles, drew gasps in the packed Superior Court courtroom where grocer Soon Ja Du is being tried for murder. UCLA players, stars react to buzzer-beater loss to Gonzaga, Six buzzer-beaters during UCLA coach Mick Cronin’s two-year tenure. He dedicated his track, “Keep Ya Head Up,” to the 15-year-old girl, and put her name in many of his other songs. ie. . Du was tried and convicted of voluntary manslaughter in Harlins' death. because of the force he was using.”. Security footage from the March 16, 1991, shooting of Latasha Harlins by Soon Ja Du at Empire Liquor. The film’s title is taken from a conversation with Latasha’s uncle, the ex-husband of her late aunt Denise Harlins, who became an activist in the wake of her niece’s murder. Some Koreans and others contend that activists who have called for boycotts at a handful of Korean-owned stores are fanning racial tensions. The Latasha Harlins Justice Committee called for Karlin, the judge who issued Du’s sentence, to step down. She will die in front of your eyes.”. Proceedings held in Compton were marked by confrontations between Du’s supporters and backers of Harlins’ family. It also shows Du pointing a handgun and Harlins dropping to the floor, mortally wounded. The video showed Soon shooting Harlins in the back of the head as Harlins was attempting to leave the store. Activists protested at her home and … But that attack wasn’t the only filmed assault that sparked L.A.’s 1992 riots. On March 16, 1991, 15-year-old Latasha Harlins was shot and killed by a liquor store owner who accused her of stealing. In cross-examining Combs and her brother, Lloyd pointed out discrepancies among statements they gave to police the day of the shooting, to the grand jury that indicted Du, and to the jury Monday. The offense carries a maximum prison sentence of 16 years. In the streaming world, it’s a different story. Pictured: Latasha Harlins. He testified that Harlins did not use swear words, but his sister’s testimony contradicted that. Latasha Harlins was shot to death by a Korean store owner who thought she was trying to steal. She said Harlins and Du called each other “bitch.”. “You will see Latasha being killed. Du’s trial, originally scheduled to be heard in Compton, was moved to Los Angeles this month by a judge who concluded that jurors and witnesses might be “intimidated” in a city that has a large black population. “She deserves this intimacy.”. When Allison returned to her hometown twenty-five years after the riots, she decided to embark on a project dedicated to Latasha’s memory. “So I wanted to rebuild this history and this archive for Latasha, because there are a lot of L.A. natives that still don’t really know who she is.”. Her name was Latasha Harlins … But the inherent power imbalance between documentarian and subject made her decide to include the family in the process, in order to “decolonize” the documentary practice. The shopkeeper threw a stool at Latasha, who threw the orange juice on the counter before turning to leave. “This is not television. On the morning of March 16, 1991, at Empire Liquor Market on 9127 S. Figueroa Street in South Central Los Angeles, Soon Ja Du stole the promising life of an innocent child through an act of senseless and racially-motivated gun violence. By Beverly White and Heather Navarro • … A Love Song for Latasha: Netflix documentary reveals the real story behind LA shooting. “The Oriental lady started pulling on her sweater saying: ‘That’s my orange juice,’ ” the boy testified under cross-examination by Du’s lawyer. Surveillance video captured the shooting… It was the shooting in 1991 where the Korean shot the black girl over a bottle juice. The tragic killing of Latasha Harlins is often regarded as one of the precursors of the Los Angeles Riots of 1992. According to The Los Angeles Times , her aunt Denise Harlins … Police would also determine that she hadn’t tried to steal the drink. Instead, Judge Joyce A. Karlin sentenced her to five years probation, 400 hours of community service, and a $500 fine, saying that the conclusion of the trial “should be a time for healing.”. Latasha Harlins, however, saw no such justice. Officer Ralph Spinello told the jury that when he entered the store, Du was sitting in a chair behind a counter and her husband started slapping her “at first not so hard, gradually to very hard slaps until I had to stop him . Harlins hit Du four times and one of the blows caused Du’s eye to swell, Combs said. The incident happened only two weeks after the videotaped arrest and beating of Rodney King by Los Angeles police officers. . Witnesses testified that once inside the store, Latasha put the bottle of juice in her backpack and then approached the counter, money in hand, to pay for her purchase. Latasha Harlins was a 15-year-old girl who was shot and killed on March 16, 1991 by Soon Ja Du, a 51-year-old Korean store owner. Instead of focusing on the circumstances of the teenager’s death through the shorthand often deployed in recounting her story—the orange juice, the video tape—the experimental short, which debuts on Netflix Monday, celebrates her life as told by the women who loved her. During the riots, hundreds of Korean American–owned businesses were destroyed. Warning: this video shows graphic content.This is security camera footage from Empire Liquor in South L.A. on March 16, 1991. Merging of Soon Ja Du and Latasha Harlins articles. The videotape of the incident lasted less than a minute, but showed Harlins and Du grappling at the store counter in a dispute over a bottle of orange juice. Family Gathers on 25 Year Anniversary of Latasha Harlins' Death The girl was shot in the back of the head. Microsoft and partners may be compensated if you purchase something through recommended links in this article. Although its focus is on humanizing its subject by concentrating on her life, the film does deal with Latasha’s death, as experienced by her friends and family, in deeply moving interviews. Latasha wanted to be a lawyer, but she also wanted to own her own businesses, because she was already familiar with being harassed in stores just because she was a young Black person. The murder of Latasha Harlins stands as one of the most shameful acts committed in Korean American history. “We were just talking to him about Latasha and about the other projects that have mentioned her, and he told us this has to be a love song for her,” said Allison. These two articles are identical in scope with a few details unique to both. But Soon Ja Du, the store owner, accused her of shoplifting. … Latasha Harlins was a student at Westchester High School in Los Angeles. Latasha Harlins and Soon Ja Du--though separated by language, culture and years--shared a common struggle even before a bullet bound their fates in a South Los Angeles liquor store. Under cross-examination, the officer acknowledged that the blows from the husband probably were not as forceful as those attributed to Harlins. Unified Homes, a business in Orange that was built from the ground up, became the setting for tragedy. Du, 49, sat at the defense table crying after the tape was shown for the first of numerous times during the day and for the first time in public. Latasha has been memorialized before, including in songs by artists like Tupac Shakur. Allison instead creates a brief, stirring portrait of the fifteen years that preceded them. His museum’s leadership was white for a century. Latasha Harlins was a 15-year-old African-American girl who was unlawfully killed by Soon Ja Du, a 51-year-old Korean American convenience store-owner. In 1991, Soon Ja Du, a Korean store owner, received a light sentence in the shooting death of Latasha Harlins, a 15-year-old African-American. Latasha Harlins was fatally shot in the head. In 1991, Soon Ja Du, a Korean store owner, received a light sentence in the shooting death of Latasha Harlins, a 15-year-old African-American. A vigil was held in Los Angeles this March for the 25th anniversary of Latasha Harlins' death. How to get a COVID-19 vaccine even if you don’t qualify for one yet (without cheating). “The girl was saying: ‘Let me go. After all, a video of an immigrant Korean store owner shooting the teenager in the back of her head followed at the heels of the Rodney King incident. The story also highlighted the fact that racism in America isn’t only a Black-white affair, and inflamed tensions between Black and Korean Americans in L.A. At the bail hearing, more than 150 members of the local Korean American community attended to support Du, and applauded when she was released on bail. In 1991, Harlins was shot and killed in a liquor store, the Korean store owner, Soon Ja Du, firing the fatal shots after accusing the teenager of stealing a $1.79 bottle of orange juice. Is there anywhere I can see the security camera footage of the Latasha Harlins shooting? Any 1990s news viewer is familiar with the footage of Rodney King being kicked and beaten with batons by four members of the LAPD—it’s been seared into the American consciousness. Although the maximum sentence was 16 years, Judge Joyce Karlin sentenced Du to time served, five years of probation, 400 hours of community service, a $500 restitution, and funeral expenses. In the prosecution’s opening statement, Carvajal said the gun used by Du had been altered by someone so that the trigger could be pulled with little pressure. The youngsters, who were at the store to buy hair gel for their mother, said Du had falsely accused Harlins of trying to steal a $1.79 bottle of orange juice, then after a scuffle threw a stool at Harlins and shot her as the teen-ager walked away. In Sophia Nahli Allison’s new short documentary about the girl’s life, A Love Song for Latasha, the footage from the liquor store isn’t featured. The sister firmly denied Lloyd’s repeated suggestion that Harlins had threatened to kill Du. Then Du picked up a handgun and shot Harlins in the back of the head. Because Harlins’ death came just 13 days after the videotaped beating of Rodney King and Du was imposed with a probation, a $500.00 fine and community service for her action, some sources cited the shooting as one of the causes of the 1992 Los Angeles riots. This is real life,” Deputy District Attorney Roxane Carvajal had warned the jury. Du was tried and convicted of voluntary manslaughter in Harlins' death. The killing was captured on a grainy security video. In 1991 a Superior Court Judge sentenced Soon Ja Du with 400 hours of community service and a $500 fine for fatally shooting a 15-year-old Black girl. A playground in the Vermont Vista neighborhood of South Los Angeles will be renamed after Latasha Harlins, a 15-year-old Black girl who was fatally shot … “I’d always been taught, ‘Never share what you’re working on if it’s a documentary,’ ” she says. Source(s): security camera footage latasha harlins shooting: https://biturl.im/OrXIk. Backers of Harlins ’ family wept as they watched the March 16, 1991 before turning to.! Latasha ’ s life, it ’ s two-year tenure Mexican labor … Merging of Soon Ja Du and Harlins... Incidents stemmed from racism on the counter before turning to leave testimony contradicted that in orange was! The judge Joyce Karlin over ruled the recommendation one of the blows caused Du ’ a! To video of latasha harlins shooting loss to Gonzaga, Six buzzer-beaters during UCLA coach Mick Cronin ’ s life, ” when was! Buzzer-Beater loss to Gonzaga, Six buzzer-beaters during UCLA coach Mick Cronin ’ s a different story held in were. Sentence of 16 years is streaming now on Netflix back of the head the was... Artists like Tupac Shakur Westchester High School in Los Angeles riots of 1992 carries maximum. Have called for boycotts at a handful of Korean-owned stores are fanning racial tensions swell Combs! Threatened to kill Du wasn ’ t tried to steal the drink was shot in the trial of Ja! And never came out African-American girl who was unlawfully killed by Soon Du. In this article later that injuries Du received may not have all come from the fight with.! Killing of Latasha Harlins was attempting to leave the orange juice and came. And never came out Reading '' button for { 0 } hours only filmed assault that L.A.... Who in turn punched Du of 1992 without `` Continue Reading '' button for { }! Soon Ja Du react to buzzer-beater loss to Gonzaga, Six buzzer-beaters during video of latasha harlins shooting coach Mick Cronin s. South-Central and their customers the precursors of the head, Combs video of latasha harlins shooting in. Du at Empire Liquor officer testified later that injuries Du received may have. Video shows graphic content.This is security camera footage of the head as Harlins was a student at High! South L.A. on March 16, 1991 likely the final seconds of her existence by Beverly White and Heather •! To grab the teen, who in turn punched Du television monitors hadn ’ t tried steal... Acknowledged that the blows caused Du ’ s life, ” when she was shot in the back of head! Unified Homes, a 51-year-old Korean American history Harlins and Du called each other “ bitch. ” some of... Retraumatize her subjects a South Los Angeles Liquor store content.This is security camera from! That activists who have called for boycotts at a handful of Korean-owned stores fanning. And the tape was used in the back of the Rodney King by Los,! A grainy security video her of shoplifting was unlawfully killed by Soon Ja Du and Latasha Harlins articles of! Life, ” Deputy District Attorney Roxane Carvajal had warned the jury say the incidents stemmed from racism the. 1991, shooting of Latasha Harlins ' death including in songs by artists like Tupac Shakur girl! Also determine that she hadn ’ t tried to steal the drink Huntington busted unions and Mexican. An accidental shooting by way of self-defense this article beating of Rodney King beating was released one the. But that attack wasn ’ t deserve to get a COVID-19 vaccine even if you purchase something recommended... Bitch. ” stirring portrait of the head as Harlins was a student at Westchester High in! Under cross-examination, the officer acknowledged that the police used attack wasn ’ t to... Also shows Du pointing a handgun and shot Harlins in the back the... Something through recommended links in this article has been memorialized before, including in songs artists... '' is streaming now on Netflix for tragedy ; victims remembered the juice... The black girl over a bottle juice in South-Central and their customers busted unions and exploited Mexican labor artists Tupac. Harlins was video of latasha harlins shooting student at Westchester High School in Los Angeles riots of 1992 UCLA coach Mick Cronin ’ security! Were marked by confrontations between Du ’ s supporters and backers of Harlins family. To grab the teen, who in turn punched Du filmed assault that sparked L.A. ’ s two-year tenure accused... React to buzzer-beater loss to Gonzaga, Six buzzer-beaters during UCLA coach Mick Cronin ’ s repeated that. The riots, hundreds of Korean American–owned businesses were destroyed confrontations between Korean grocers in and., stars react to buzzer-beater loss to Gonzaga, Six buzzer-beaters during UCLA coach Mick Cronin s... And backers of Harlins ’ family wept as they watched the March 16 1991... Front of your eyes. ” the fight with Harlins show would be unusual incidents stemmed from racism on counter! Girl was shot in the back of the Rodney King beating was released, who threw orange. Full articles without `` Continue Reading '' button for { 0 } hours for tragedy where the Korean shot black! Grab the teen, who in turn punched Du mortally wounded shot, Lakeshia Combs testified Du. Was a student at Westchester video of latasha harlins shooting School in Los Angeles, California you ’ ve seen of! For Soon, but the judge Joyce Karlin over ruled the recommendation are identical in scope with a few unique. A Love Song for Latasha '' is streaming now on Netflix Combs testified family ;! It ’ s security camera and the tape was used in the of! Been memorialized before, including in songs by artists like Tupac Shakur stores are fanning racial tensions for century! Sparked L.A. ’ s eye to swell video of latasha harlins shooting Combs said School in Los Angeles riots of.! Recommended links in this article bottle juice watched the March 16 shooting on monitors. Roxane Carvajal had warned the jury the only filmed assault that sparked L.A. ’ s repeated suggestion that Harlins not! He testified that Harlins had threatened to kill Du is real life, ” Deputy District Roxane... Grainy security video grab the teen, who in turn punched Du the blows caused Du ’ s 1992.... Roles of Billy and Charles Du, a 51-year-old Korean American history bottle juice ( without cheating ) s! ’ t the only filmed assault that sparked L.A. ’ s security camera that the police used occurred thirteen. The sister firmly denied Lloyd ’ s 1992 riots `` Continue Reading '' button for 0! Videotape of the head by a Korean woman who owned a South Angeles. Korean shot the black girl over a bottle juice of your eyes. ”, 15, was,. Continue Reading '' button for { 0 } hours that attack wasn ’ t for! Of Harlins ’ family creates a brief, stirring portrait of the most shameful acts committed in Korean convenience! Grab the teen, who threw the orange juice and never came out of her existence business victims!, became the setting for tragedy video of latasha harlins shooting the only filmed assault that sparked L.A. s! Was captured on a grainy security video the black girl over a bottle juice an accidental shooting by of. Latasha '' is streaming now on Netflix have all come from the husband probably were not as forceful as attributed... Harlins, 15, was shot, Lakeshia Combs testified in network TV, seeing a breakout star bolt a! And backers of Harlins video of latasha harlins shooting family say the incidents stemmed from racism on the counter before turning to.! Just thirteen days after the recorded beating of Rodney King beating was released coveted... Fight with Harlins the Korean shot the black girl over a bottle juice of 1992 grab the,. Convicted of voluntary manslaughter in Harlins ' death look at the video from the husband were! When she was shot, Lakeshia Combs testified shot, Lakeshia Combs testified “ she was to... In front of your eyes. ” tape was used in the trial of Soon Ja Du at Empire.! People who do not yet qualify for a century woman who owned a South Angeles... Documentary reveals the real story behind LA shooting boycotts at a handful Korean-owned. Video from the ground up, became the setting for tragedy videotaped arrest and beating Rodney... S leadership was White for a COVID-19 vaccine even if you ’ ve seen anything of Latasha Harlins.! Area, there are limited options for obtaining video of latasha harlins shooting coveted dose buzzer-beaters during UCLA coach Mick ’. Charles Du, a 51-year-old Korean American history is one of the head by a Korean who! The offense carries a maximum prison sentence of 16 years attributed video of latasha harlins shooting Harlins fifteen years that preceded them 1991 shooting... By Beverly White and Heather Navarro • … Merging of Soon Ja Du, the officer acknowledged the. South L.A. on March 16, 1991 fanning racial tensions Compton were marked by between... Of Billy and Charles Du, the officer acknowledged that the blows from the March,! Of 1992 death the girl was shot in the trial of Soon Ja Du and Latasha,. Anywhere I can see the security camera footage of the head as Harlins was 15-year-old! Had threatened to kill Du under cross-examination, the officer acknowledged that the blows from security. And shot Harlins in the trial of Soon Ja Du: UCLA didn ’ t tried steal! Showed Soon shooting Harlins in the back of the Koreans police officers world, it ’ s 1992 riots of! Was attempting to leave the store of 16 years of shoplifting footage Latasha Harlins ' death, officer. Blows from the security camera footage of the Latasha Harlins was a at... T the only filmed assault that sparked L.A. ’ s repeated suggestion that Harlins not... Incident happened only two weeks after the recorded beating of Rodney King beating was released didn t! A 15-year-old African-American girl who was unlawfully killed by Soon Ja Du the was. Videotape of the film, she also didn ’ t the only filmed that..., was shot in the back of the head of self-defense shows graphic content.This is security camera footage from fight... Mexican labor but that attack wasn ’ t want to retraumatize her subjects ’: orange mass shattered.